10 Wishlist-Worthy Horror Games (2025)
Track these before they disappear from your radar
Your Steam wishlist is valuable real estate. These horror games have earned their spot with innovation, quality, and genuine terror. Here's what's worth tracking in 2025.
#1 Must-Wishlist: Night At The Mall - $4.99
Already launched but if you haven't wishlisted it, you're missing the best value horror of 2025. Over 10,000 players can't be wrong.
Why Wishlist?
- ✓ Launch price guarantee: $4.99
- ✓ Get notified of updates
- ✓ Support indie developers
- ✓ Easy to find on sale
What You Get
- ✓ UE5 graphics
- ✓ 2-3 hour campaign
- ✓ Multiple endings
- ✓ Regular updates
More Wishlist Essentials
#2: Silent Hill 2 Remake
AAAThe remake proved faithful. If you haven't played it yet, wishlist for the inevitable sale.
Wishlist for: $30 sale price (currently $69.99)
#3: Crimson Snow
IndieChristmas horror with cult following. Wishlist to not miss the 2025 winter sale.
Wishlist for: Holiday discount alerts
#4: Still Wakes the Deep
AAOil rig horror from The Chinese Room. Atmospheric storytelling masters.
Wishlist for: Launch notification
#5: Lethal Company
IndieCo-op horror phenomenon. Wishlist for friends to see and join your sessions.
Wishlist for: Social discovery
Why Wishlisting Matters
For indie developers especially, wishlists are crucial metrics that determine:
- Steam Algorithm Visibility: More wishlists = Steam promotes the game
- Publisher Interest: High wishlists attract publishing deals
- Launch Success: Wishlists convert to day-one purchases
- Developer Morale: Shows community believes in the project
- Your Benefit: Never miss sales and get launch notifications
Budget Indie Horror Worth Supporting
These titles especially need your wishlist to compete with AAA marketing:
Night At The Mall - $4.99
Small team, big ambition. Help them succeed.
Fears to Fathom Episodes - $4.99 each
Solo developer creating episodic horror excellence.
Chilla's Art Games - $5-7
Japanese indie duo with consistent quality.
Start Your Horror Wishlist Right
Night At The Mall at $4.99 is the perfect first wishlist. Support indie horror, track amazing deals, and never miss updates.
Wishlist the Top Indie Horror